PASCALL PRIZE FOR CRITICAL WRITING
 
 2001  Judges' Report
 
Elizabeth Farrelly
 
The Pascall Prize aims each year to identify and reward a critical writer whose work stimulates and engages the reader. The writing of Pascall Prize winners must have what it takes to be read and appreciated for its own sake, not simply our of interest in the subject at hand.

The winner of the 2001 Pascall Prize is the Sydney Morning Herald's architecture critic, Dr Elizabeth Farrelly. Her writing has pace and style, and she effectively combines academic and theoretical knowledge with strong opinions. The voice that emerges is clear and powerfully expressed. "You really get the sense of a coherent point of view pulsing through her work", said a judge.

Dr Farrelly writes about a difficult subject - the built environment - with elan and a sense of humour, and she is able to communicate complicated ideas in an entertaining way. She helps us understand, as one judge put it, "by a mixture of history, context and gritty critique".

"This woman has a gift" said another. "She moves effortlessly between the highbrow and the colloquial, reflecting changes not just in voice, but thought. Her arguments link tangible visual impressions with ambient theory and historical surveys. The pictures that she throws up are the result of scholarship; deep thinking about the role and destiny of the built environment."

It should be remembered, however, that Dr Farrelly wins because she writes beautifully, not because she knows a lot about architecture. Or as one judge put it: "And then there's her language. What a pleasure, and what a signature idiom!...This is vivacious writing and it's going to be hard to match."

Another judge said: " I want a writer to grab the prize, by which I mean someone who loves words and the way they rub against each other".

Architectural issues are rarely treated seriously and readably for consumers of daily newspaper journalism. Cutting through manifest pretension and enabling laypeople to gain a better and more informed understanding of the constructions around them is something to applaud - and a signal example of the critic's art. The judges acknowledge the Sydney Morning Herald and its editors for providing Dr Farrelly with regular opportunities and sufficient space to explore matters of crucial importance to our lives.

 

2001 Judges
Gay Bilson
Bruce Elder
Andrew Ford
Sandra Hall
Robert Nelson
Adrian Read (Convenor)
 
 
 
 
 
 
                    Created by Justin Davis     |     This site was created for 1024 x 768 screen resolution    |    Disclaimer   |   Last modified: 27-05-10
                           Acrobat reader is required for some content on this site. Click the icon to download Acrobat Reader