PASCALL PRIZE FOR CRITICAL WRITING
 
 2009 Judges' Report
 
Alison Croggon       
     

At a time when newspapers and magazines are reducing the space devoted to critical writing, Alison Croggon is one of a small number of commentators who has adapted to the new opportunities of online criticism, while maintaining a presence in a mainstream newspaper. Her writing is passionate and clear, and informed by a long-time devotion to theatre, as well as other forms of writing. She can criticise, without patronising, understanding that a critic must back up opinion with analysis. Her breadth of experience is impressive, as is the generosity of spirit evident in much of her writing. Croggon’s newspaper criticism is precise and efficient, using the limited space to be informative but still entertaining. You understand why she has made her judgements, but she also allows the reader sufficient room to make up her or his own mind about a work. Her online blogging and reviewing is more expansive, but keeps a theoretical and analytical rigour often missing from online writing. Croggon has embraced the benefits of the online medium, conscientiously responding to the often-divergent comments made on her blog and encouraging debate. In this way she has acknowledged the changing nature of the contemporary critic, a role that is shifting away from the assertion of opinion to a mute audience, and towards the curation of a public conversation.

2009 JUDGING PANEL

Kate Eltham

Robert Forster

Leo Schofield

Rosemary Sorensen

Adrian Read (convenor)

   

 

 

 
 
 
 
                    Created by Justin Davis     |     This site was created for 1024 x 768 screen resolution    |    Disclaimer   |   Last modified: 27-05-10
                           Acrobat reader is required for some content on this site. Click the icon to download Acrobat Reader